The case for standard forms of construction contract. Lump sum construction contract its advantages and disadvantages in lump sum construction contract contractor bids a single fixed price for all activities in the project scope. I strongly believe that using a boq instead of a schedule of prices for payments has no use, especially considering that the design will be 100% complete, i. Is a lump sum contract a feature of a design and build. The disadvantage is that the project cost may exceed the estimated cost if there were errors in quantities mentioned in the boq and the final billed quantities exceed the specified quantities in the lump sum contract the variations in cost is borne by the contractor.
It is called a lump sum because the contractor is required to submit a total and global price instead of bidding on individual items. Also known as a lumpsum contract, fixed price billing is based on a detailed estimate that gives a total cost for the entire project. In the law of legal costs, there has long been a distinction between a lump sum bill, of the kind generally given in the first instance by solicitors to clients with whom they have an ongoing working relationship, and an itemized bill which is usually given if a client wants a bit more detail in relation to how the hell legal costs could possibly have blown out to the amount stated in the. Lump sum construction contract united nations office for. Insights from qatar evaluating variations on lump sum. The case for standard forms of construction contract tj mukasa, mrics, iciob, aisu a contractors submission of a claim for loss and expense is often thought to be the result of a poorly managed project that has gone wrong in some way.
Traditional lump sum tls methods have been the primary procurement method within australia. Which costs are subject to audit, who bears the expense of the audit, and who has the. The lump sum construction contract what seems to be the. Thus, such contracts help to reduce disputes or breaches of contract, since there are less detailed terms to work with. Jul 18, 2019 a lump sum contract is normally used in the construction industry to reduce design and contract administration costs. The use of lump sum bills of quantities contracts for civil. Total all of the amounts bid for each pay item and show the total bid amount. A lump sum price should cover all costs, overheads, risk contingencies and profit. When the words lump sum appear as a unit bid price, insert an amount bid for each lump sum pay item. Fitzmaurice, any lump sum contract is executed on the basis that the contractor has to execute all that indispensably required to complete a known scope of works.
It is defined as a fixed price contract, where the contractors agree to execute the work for a stated total sum of money. In our contracts the price is usually paid in stages, which may be subject to a price fluctuation. Contract quantities contract administration the wifcon. Jun 27, 20 initially the project were lump sum tendered based on bill of quantities and upon finalization of contract both the employer and contractor have agreed to convert the contract to a lump sum contract based on drawings and specification with modified method of measurement for interim payment process. Lump sum contract advantages and disadvantages in construction. Deductions for omitting items in bill of quantities. Lump sum construction contract advantages and disadvantages.
Advantages of lump sum construction contract for owner are as follows. Builders bill a software for billing of lumpsum contracts website. Dec 11, 2019 lump sum and measurement are both types construction contracts. Nov 09, 2017 bills of quantities are prepared by quantity surveyors and building estimators, and indeed the bill of quantities was the reason for the development of quantity surveying as a separate profession. Discuss whether or not you agree with this view, making reference to the contractual basis on which.
Fixedprice or lump sum contract project management. In a lump sum contract, the parties agree to one price based on the contractors estimate of the total costs of the project. Bills of quantities are prepared by quantity surveyors and building estimators, and indeed the bill of quantities was the reason for the development of quantity surveying as a separate profession. Critical contract documents for every construction project. The test contractor submitted a lump sum bid prior to the actual bid letting deadline.
Oct 16, 2008 a the boq and mom will be submitted during tender phase, but it will be stated that the contract is lump sum. It fixes the price to be paid for undertaking out the work, before the start of the contract. These issues arise often when a subcontractor prices off a bill of quantities boq as part of the tender documents but when the offer is accepted, the boq is not made part of the contract and instead a lump sum price is all that is included in the contract. The use of lump sum bills of quantities contracts for. In a lumpsum contract, the client has reduced some of the. Fixedprice or lump sum contract the term firm fixed price or lump sum contract refers specifically to a type or variety of fixed price contract where the buyer or purchaser pays the seller or provider a fixed total amount for a very welldefined product, however there is the allowance within these for a variance in the event there are.
Boq helps to contractors get an itemized list of materials, equipment, and labour with their costs required to build new projects, maintain, or repair existing structures. Example 2 audit provision for cost reimbursable contract containing lump sum component. Bills support lump sum contracts and cost certainty. It also ideally details the terms and conditions of the construction or repair contract and itemizes all work to enable a contractor. A lump sum contract or stipulated sum contract is the traditional means of procuring construction, and still the most common form of construction contract. As a result, the employer and the contractor enter the contract with their commitments clear. This type of contract is often based on firm bills of quantities and drawings. Saves the heavy cost of preparing many bills of quantities by the contractors. A lump sum contract includes all the materials, labor, subcontracts, profit, and. The two parties involved are one or more owners, and one or more contractors. Lump sum construction contract is the most widely accepted contract between the owner and the contractor due to it general predictability, easy management and assured maximum price arrangements.
The lump sum contract may be used when the owner does have a complete set of construction plans, specifications etc. Bills of quantities can be converted and presented in excel or cite formats for importing into your estimating software, or delivered electronically, cd, or hard copy types of bills of quantities the main use of a bill of quantities in support of a contract is the traditional and proven means of securing a lumpsum price for carrying out the. If the quantities change, then the subcontractor is left arguing about the boq. On completion of the works, the lump sum contract price would be paid in full to the contractor subject to the approved variations. Lump sum contract is the simplest form of contract in construction. Construction contract types lump sum contract a lump sum contract, sometimes called stipulated sum, is the most basic form of agreement between a contractor and a customer. A lumpsum contract is the most recognized agreement form on simple and small projects and. A bill of quantities boq is a document used in tendering in the construction industry in which materials, parts, and labour and their costs are itemised. Apr 27, 2014 unit price advantages easy for contract selection. The department schedule of rates for various items of work are al. This method is particularly used for large construction projects and is a conventional but most popular types of construction contract.
The quantities are measured in number, length, area, volume, weight or time. The item refers to unforeseeable cost likely to be incurred during the contract. In lump sum contracts based on bill of quantities the. Normally we wont find anything related to fairness of a particular circumstance in fidic. Quantities digitized using the agtek software and the digitizer board include. Any variation in quantities may be adjusted at the time of billing. In such situation, basic nature of lump sum contract is compromised. There may also be penalties, or liquidated damages, for late termination. There are different styles of bills of quantities, mainly the elemental bill of quantities and trade bills. Lump sum fixed price is a wellestablished method of construction contracting in the middle east and many other regions of the world. Queensland, new south wales and victoria where design and construct, construction management and hybrids thereof have become the norm. Where the engineer is required to determine a matter or settle a claim he is required to consult with each of the parties to try and reach an agreement.
Computer software, has, however, significantly simplified and. Fixedprice or lump sum contract project management knowledge. However matters are not so simple, and provisions for. Lump sum contracts can include benefits or incentives for termination that happens early. Extending this principle it is reasonable to suggest that how the contractor has priced the bid in a lump sum contract is a matter for the bidder and should not affect the payment terms. If it is presumed that quantities do not form a term in lump sum contracts unless the contract states otherwise, the contractor will not be paid any additional payment if the quantities required to be executed are greater than stated in the bill of quantity, portman and fotheringham v pildritch 1904,priestly v stone 1888, re ford and. The practice historically of estimating building costs in this way arose from noncontractual measurements, taken off drawings to assist tenderers in quoting lump sum prices. In this type of contract, a contractor is required to quote fixed sum for execution of work complete in all respect in the stipulated time to him with the tender. I have just returned from presenting our 2day construction claims intensive training course in qatar where one delegate raised a question in connection with lump sum contracts and items included in the bills of quantities, but not shown on the drawings. The work required is measured and described precisely. The contractor was engaged as a lump sum test contractor on sp500725. Types of bill of quantities designing buildings wiki.
This research used a test contractor to bid a unit priced contract as a lump sum contract. Lump sum contract, for the purposes of this circular means a contract where the quantities are substantially measured firm and the final price to be paid is ascertained by adding todeducting from the contractors accepted tender price the value of variations and other specified items e. A bill of quantities boq is a document used in tendering in the construction industry in which materials, parts, and labour. Bills of quantities, schedule of quantities rates or contract sum analysis on design and build projects schedules of work. Is a lump sum contract a feature of a design and build contract. Intermediate payment is made for i value of measure up items of work executed forming part of the contract. However, dont assume that a lump sum price is a fixed price or that it will be the final price. Lump sum contract designing buildings wiki share your construction industry knowledge.
Bill of quantities bq or boq is prepared by the clients quantity surveyor or cost manager. Bills of quantities that are required for a lump sum contract based on firm or approximate quantities will normally be prepared by the employers quantity surveyor, whereas under a design and build contract, the employers project team will prepare the employers requirements and the bill of quantities or quantified schedules of work will. In the law of legal costs, there has long been a distinction between a lump sum bill, of the kind generally given in the first instance by solicitors to clients with whom they have an ongoing working relationship, and an itemized bill which is usually given if a client wants a bit more detail in relation to how the hell legal costs could possibly have blown out to the amount stated in the lump. A construction contract is a mutual or legally binding agreement between two parties based on policies and conditions recorded in document form. Difference between lump sum and measurement contracts. Under a lump sum contract, a single lump sum price for all the works is agreed before the works begin. Fidic is the international federation of consulting engineers, known by its french acronym. A firm bill of quantities is used to obtain a lumpsum price for a fullydesigned project. This was the central issue that the high court had to decide in the recent case of. In a lump sum non remeasurable contract, the works shall not be remeasured for payment purposes. A lump sum contract is the most common pricing arrangement for construction contracts. The standard forms of contract normally used for civil engineering adopt the bills of quantities for remeasurement. A contingency sum is an item found within a bill of quantities. The use of lump sum bills of quantities contracts for civil engineering works 1.
If agreement cannot be reached the engineer must make a fair. In comparing with lump sum contract, changes in contract documents can be made easily by the owner. This contract has a total fixed price for all activities related to construction. Considering the demands of clients, the increasing propensity.
However, as two recent cases highlight, defining a lump sum contract may not always be as straightforward as might be supposed. What is the difference between a lump sum contract and an. When the words contingent sum or a fixed rate appears as a unit bid price, include the government inserted amount bid for the item in the total bid amount. Lump sum contract is the simplest form of contract in construction projects.
This allows a contractor who has a lump sum contract for improvement to real property to pay sales or use tax on the cost of materials for the project using lump sum or progress billings, not on the amount of materials shown as billed to the general contractor or owner. A lump sum contract or fixed fee contract is a traditional means of procurement in which a single lump sum price for all of the works is agreed upon before the works starts. The owner has full authority to decide what type of contract should be used for a specific development to be constructed and to set forth the legally. In the building industry the price is usually a lump sum, and the bills are intended to be simply a guide to allow the price to be determined. For pure lump sum contracts the contractor undertakes to carry out a defined amount of work in return for an agreed price. A lump sum building contract usually provides that the contractor bears. A lumpsum contract is normally used in the construction industry to reduce design and contract administration costs. A bill of quantities is a document used in tendering in the construction industry in which materials, parts, and labor and their costs are itemized. Common mistakes in lump sum contracts comment building. A lump sum refers to the single aggregate price a contractor offers to undertake the work and cover all risks accepted by the contractor under the contract. Thus, such contracts help to reduce disputes or breaches of contract. Lump sum andor schedule of ratesbills of quantities contracts retention andor bank guarantee details progress payments can be entered by amount, percentage or quantity and allows processing both claimed and approved values, net or gross. May 29, 2009 traditional lump sum tls methods have been the primary procurement method within australia. Bill of quantities advantages and disadvantages boq.
Aug 27, 2018 bill of quantities bq or boq is prepared by the clients quantity surveyor or cost manager. The lump sum bidding process is designed to reduce cost overruns so as to minimize cost growth of projects and to share the risk of additional material quantities with contractors. World bank recommends pricing structure procurement office. Bill of quantity items, quantities and descriptions are at contractors risk. A lump sum contract is normally used in the construction industry to reduce design and contract administration costs. A lump sum contract or a stipulated sum contract will require that the contractor agree to provide specified services for a stipulated or fixed price. There is an option for payment to be on the basis of a lump sum.
Omission of items included in the bill of quantities, but. A lump sum contract is the most recognized agreement form on simple and small projects and. In comparing with lumpsum contract, changes in contract documents can be made easily by the owner. In some instances, contract states that it is a lump sum contract, however, few bills of the boq states that these are the provisional quantities and it shall be remeasured as per actual execution at site. Bills of quantities that are required for a lump sum contract based on firm or. Advice on suitability of contractors for tendering bills of quantities prepared by our practice have the following uses, and these are borne in mind by the quantity surveyor during their preparation. Quantity tabulations and bill of materials for some items such as the.
A hard bid essentially says, no matter what, were building it for this amount of money. I have just returned from presenting our 2day construction claims intensive training course in qatar where one delegate raised a question in connection with lumpsum contracts and items included in the bills of quantities, but not shown on the drawings. The production of bills of quantities referred to as bills for the rest of the study as a means of obtaining. Lump sum and measurement are both types construction contracts. The term firm fixed price or lump sum contract refers specifically to a type or variety of fixed price contract where the buyer or purchaser pays the seller or provider a fixed total amount for a very welldefined product, however there is the allowance within these for a variance in the event there are incentives attained through project incentives achieved or targets met. Between 1 united nations office for project services unops, an organ of the united. It is called a lumpsum because the contractor is required to submit a total and global price instead of bidding on individual items. Audit provisions in private construction contracts. A lump sum contract may be used where the contractor is able to provide an accurate estimate of the costs of the project, including the schedule and the scope of the entire project.
1579 71 160 720 1505 1154 1331 242 1408 1309 1289 861 427 700 806 41 1549 245 45 1488 8 1475 343 1481 207 1639 868 1393 1136 954 458 805 1082 1432